Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell)

/ 15:15 / E480

What Does “Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell)” Talk About?

This episode of the Fatrank Podcast features James Dooley and Craig Campbell diving deep into why personal branding has become essential for SEO consultants in today's digital landscape. The conversation opens with Craig explaining how a strong personal brand acts as a safety net, meaning that even if his website were hacked or taken down, his YouTube channel and social media presence would keep his business alive. He also shares the eye-opening story of how a video of him discussing PBNs in an Amsterdam coffee shop negatively impacted the sale multiplier of one of his assets, which was the moment that convinced him to take control of his own narrative online.

The hosts discuss practical first steps for building a personal brand, covering everything from attending conferences and local meetups to creating YouTube content and engaging in Facebook groups. Craig recalls how he started building his brand around 2015 after leaving his agency, and James shares how attending a Chester meetup and eventually speaking at a conference in Shanghai accelerated his own visibility. They also address the challenge of getting onto established podcasts as an unknown, emphasising that trust must be earned before anyone will hand over access to their audience. The discussion wraps up with a debate about which social media platforms are most valuable for SEO consultants, with YouTube, LinkedIn, and Facebook coming out on top, while also touching on how Instagram content is now being indexed and surfaced in AI tools like ChatGPT.

“I may as well just take ownership of the messaging that I want to deliver for me. So if I don't sort my personal brand out, I'm just allowing somebody else to deliver that message.”

— Craig Campbell

Who Are the Guests on “Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell)”?

Craig Campbell is a veteran SEO consultant and digital marketing expert who began building his personal brand around 2015 after stepping away from running an agency. Over more than a decade he has spoken at major international conferences including events in Shanghai, built a substantial YouTube following, and developed a reputation as one of the most recognisable figures in the SEO industry. His experience spans organic SEO, brand building, asset sales, and online reputation management, and he is known for sharing candid, experience-led insights rather than theoretical advice.

James Dooley is an entrepreneur and SEO consultant who hosts the Fatrank Podcast and runs PromoSEO, a lead generation agency for SEO consultants that recently received recognition as the Best SEO Consultants Lead Generation Agency. James was initially reluctant to put himself in front of a camera but has spent roughly the last two to three years building his personal brand through YouTube and podcast content. He got his start in the speaking circuit through local SEO meetups in Chester and credits Craig Campbell with helping him secure his first major international speaking engagement in Shanghai.

What Are the Key Takeaways From “Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell)”?

Here are the key points discussed in this episode:

  • A strong personal brand protects your business from single points of failure such as a website being hacked or taken down, because your audience and reputation exist independently across multiple platforms.
  • Failing to manage your personal brand means someone else will define your reputation for you, which can directly reduce the sale multiplier when you try to exit a business asset.
  • Networking at live events such as local meetups and industry conferences remains one of the most cost-effective ways to build a personal brand, as demonstrated by James's path from a Chester meetup to speaking in Shanghai.
  • Creating in-depth content that answers real questions people are asking in forums and Facebook groups is a proven flywheel strategy for building trust and authority from scratch.
  • Instagram and other social platforms are increasingly valuable not just for audience growth but for influencing how AI tools like ChatGPT describe you, since these platforms are now being indexed and surfaced in LLM responses.

“You attach your brand now to any new kind of AI tool and it's going to explode. Why? Because you've already got the big following. So the minute you turn around on your TikToks, on Instagram, on YouTube and you promote this brand, straight away you've got eyes on the new brand that you want.”

— Craig Campbell

Is “Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell)” Worth Listening To?

This episode is worth listening to because it goes far beyond generic personal branding advice and grounds every point in real experiences that Craig and James have lived through. The story about Craig losing negotiating power on an asset sale because a buyer found a video of him talking about PBNs is the kind of specific, costly lesson that most people only share in private. That single example reframes personal branding from a vanity exercise into a genuine financial asset protection strategy, which is a perspective that is rarely articulated this clearly.

The conversation is also valuable because both hosts are candid about what does not work, including the difficulty of cold-pitching yourself onto established podcasts, the limitations of TikTok for SEO audiences, and the slow grind of growing an Instagram following. Rather than selling a shortcut, Craig and James give a realistic picture of the time and investment involved, from years of conference travel to hundreds of hours of YouTube content. For SEO consultants who are trying to decide where to focus their energy in 2025 and beyond, the platform discussion alone, covering YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, and the emerging role of Instagram in AI indexing, offers genuinely actionable guidance.

Who Should Listen to “Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell)”?

This episode is ideal for:

  • SEO consultants who want to generate more inbound enquiries and command higher rates by building a recognisable personal brand
  • Digital marketers and agency owners considering selling a business asset and wanting to understand how their personal reputation affects valuation
  • Entrepreneurs who are early in their career and looking for a realistic, step-by-step framework for gaining industry visibility without a large budget
  • Content creators and podcasters in the marketing space who want to understand which platforms deliver the best return for B2B audiences in the current AI-driven search landscape

Where Can You Listen to Fatrank Podcast?

You can listen to Fatrank Podcast on all major podcast platforms:

  • Apple Podcasts – Search for “Fatrank Podcast” in the Podcasts app
  • Spotify – Available on Spotify for free
  • Amazon Music / Audible – Listen through your Amazon account
  • Overcast – For iOS users who prefer a dedicated podcast app
  • Pocket Casts – Cross-platform podcast player

You can also subscribe using the RSS feed: https://feeds.transistor.fm/fatrank-podcast

What Are Listeners Saying About This Episode?

★★★★★

“The story about Craig losing money on an asset sale because of an old PBN video was genuinely eye-opening. I never thought about personal branding as something that directly affects your exit multiple, but it makes complete sense. Really practical episode with none of the usual fluffy advice.”

— Daniel F.

★★★★★

“I appreciated how honest both James and Craig were about the years of grind involved, from local Chester meetups to flying to Shanghai. It set realistic expectations while still being motivating. The part about Instagram posts being pulled into ChatGPT responses was a detail I had never considered before.”

— Sophie R.

★★★★★

“The section on getting onto other people's podcasts was refreshingly blunt. Craig basically said you have to earn trust before anyone will put you in front of their audience, which is something podcast booking agencies will never tell you. Saved me from wasting money on one of those services.”

— Marcus T.

This video explains which digital marketing strategies SEO consultants should focus on in 2026 to improve trust, business valuations and inbound enquiries. James Dooley and Craig Campbell start with KPI tracking because measuring brand reach and engagement shows whether your personal brand is actually converting into opportunities and revenue. They cover brand SEO, AI visibility and Google Business Profiles because stronger search presence improves trust and conversion rates.

The discussion also explores organic SEO, organic social media and paid social ads because consistent visibility across search and social supports long term growth. PPC is analysed in detail because campaign setup, landing pages and lead handling directly affect results. They also discuss Reddit, Quora and paid AI ads because diversified enquiry sources and early adoption can strengthen digital marketing performance for SEO consultants.

PromoSEO lead generation for SEO consultants recently received recognition as the “Best SEO Consultants Lead Generation Agency.”

Where to Listen to This Episode

Why Personal Branding Matters More Than Ever for SEO Consultants (with Craig Campbell) is available on:

James Dooley: Is personal branding important? So, Craig, obviously you've got an amazing personal brand. And you've had it for a long time as well. You was probably one of the first I seen properly scale out and build a great personal brand. So, how important do you think personal branding is?

Craig Campbell: I think in today's day and age, it it's very important. You know, I personally, let's say my website got wiped out, taken down, hacked, forgot to renew it sometime, instead it's not going to be death for me as a business because I've got a personal brand that, you know, I can go to my YouTube and make money. I can go to my social media and make money. And and you know, stuff that we we we spoke about in other um sessions. So, I think building that personal brand and building that trust and everything's been massively beneficial. It's been good for me. Um and I'm not saying I was the first person to ever do it cuz there was obviously people I looked at and and they were doing it and stuff like that, but everyone knew and it seems to be want to build a personal brand and and thinks it's all easy and it's all quick, big money and all that kind of stuff. But, I I think it it's massively important to do in today's market. You see influencers out there building their personal brands and you know, they're they're making money and stuff like that. So, I I think it it creates again opportunity and and everything else. It just leads you down certain paths and it's been very very good for me, but obviously you've done it as well. I know you used to say, "I don't want to talk. I don't want to do this. I want I don't want to do that." And then obviously in in years gone past, you started to dabble a bit more in it and obviously cranking out all your YouTube videos that probably only about two or three years you've been doing that right? Whereas before you were like, "I don't want to talk to anyone."

James Dooley: Yeah. So, I'm just curious, like I'd be curious to go, "Why the hell did you decide to start?"

Craig Campbell: I feel like I was forced into it in the fact that I wanted to build brands. I always understood the importance of building brands. I wasn't bothered about the light being shined on me. I wanted to shine the light on the actual corporate brands and the business brands. And then one time I looked to sell one of the assets and I didn't get the multiplier that I wanted. And the main reason was they didn't know the who was behind it. They didn't know that they could trust me the way I built the systems. In fact, it was a negative stigma of what actually happened because when they searched me, the only thing that they could find was a video of me in Amsterdam in a coffee shop talking about SEO with Matt Diggity and a few others and we was talking about PBNs. And I got asked the question on that video, "Do you think PBNs are good?" And I'm like, "Yeah, they're really powerful." Which they were, they were powerful. And it affected my multiplier cuz they thought I was hiding PBNs and it that was propping up sites. And I was like, "I don't use any PBNs for this site." And I'm like, "Well, we don't know. You're quite sophisticated in what you're doing." And I'm like, "There was no PBNs built for it. If there was, I'd tell you otherwise it could affect my earnout and stuff." But anyway, then just opened up the eyes almost of like online reputation management of being I don't want that being seen for my personal brand. It's not good for my personal brand. I want to be seen as being an entrepreneur and help businesses grow. So I thought, I may as well just take ownership of the messaging that I want to deliver for me. So if I don't sort my personal brand out, I'm just allowing somebody else to deliver that message. And I'm like, "No, I'd sooner sooner be proactive with the exact messaging, exact word for word with what I want." Gemini and ChatGPT. I mean, this was it was prior to all the AI came along, but the way the AI overviews pop up and the way Google shows who I am and what I do, I want to make sure that it's my messaging about me and not somebody else's.

James Dooley: Yeah, yeah, exactly that, yeah. I would paint a horrible picture, like etc. we've spoken about I'm consistently telling lies about you and and making people think you're a monster or a whatever. And I just do that for fun, but yeah, you don't want someone coming in and be able to paint a certain narrative of you and I think that's also something to consider. Like you say, it could damage your it could affect your earning or trust. So there's so many other benefits other than making money, but it could harm like cost you money.

Craig Campbell: Yeah, I think another massive one for me is like attracting actual A-player staff. Like people that reach out to me and want jobs. Said I want to work with you.

James Dooley: Yeah. And they wouldn't have known to want to work with me if it wasn't for my personal brand.

Craig Campbell: Yeah. You attach your brand now to any new kind of AI tool and it's going to explode. Why? Because you've already got the big following. So the minute you turn around on your TikToks, on Instagram, on YouTube and you promote this brand, straight away you've got eyes on the new brand that you want

James Dooley: Yeah. So you can go into any new business and corporate brand and with what the branding that you have from a personal point of view, boom, straight away. Yeah. It explodes. So you can connect the dots there and it's and it's great. But anyone who's watching this, man, so they've they're watching this now and they're saying, all right, I get it. I'm an entrepreneur, I'm a business owner and I want a personal brand. I've not really got any exposure. What are the first steps to building a personal brand that you say they should be maybe looking to do?

Craig Campbell: It really depends on what kind of budget and time and energy you've got. Like we've both travelled the world speaking at conferences. That costs money. PR, you know, we've we've done PR. We've spent the time on YouTube putting the you know hundreds of thousands of hours into to that as well as you know, the 20-hour flights to Shanghai you know, paying for a hotel for a week or two in Shanghai as well. So there's a lot of costs and it goes to that. There's obviously a lot of quick wins. You know, in terms of building personal branding, going to YouTube, it doesn't cost you a huge amount of money to get camera and, you know, do all of that kind of stuff. So, it really depends on how hard you want to hit it. Like, I I've built my personal brand over a probably the last 10 years. Um Yeah, probably 11. Actually, 2015 is when I gave up the agency and I thought, "I want to do this." But, obviously, I had to then do all those local meetups and everything, which is where I bumped into you in Chester, like 2016, 2017. And then, I started to get better speaking events in 2018 Shanghai, which you obviously helped with.

James Dooley: Yeah, I wouldn't have got And I've told this story anyway before, I think, in other podcasts. I wouldn't have got Shanghai if it wasn't for you. Um because I done the events. I was working for a travel company in Chester at the time. And I used to meet up with Andy Drinkwater and we used to just sit and chat And then, we used to do a meetup in in the done that thing on that meetup.com and 16 people turned up in the first one. We were just having a beer every last Thursday of every month, which is when I was down to see them. And And then, from there, we done the the meetup where I met you, which then led to speaking at Shanghai. Obviously, I'd done Brightness and various other ones as well, blogging my way in there. But then, just things happened really quickly. And then, obviously, being in Shanghai, you get more exposure. And then, before you know boom, you know, you're doing this and you're getting asked to speak there and getting asked to work with this brand and that brand. So, it all kind of happens kind of fairly quickly for me, but I wasn't against going to Shanghai and trying out. Some I I was unknown to Shanghai. I know you guys went for several years before me. And you all spoke highly of it and I've seen all the pictures and I get the All the stuff we've spoken about in other other things. You get the FOMO when you go and take bastards and I want to go to Shanghai now and be in the tuk-tuks and get pissed up and you know what, enjoy all of that experience. An experience for me wasn't necessarily anything else, but you know what, it was all about the networking and I think that's something else I would say to people is it's not always about uh what you know, it's sometimes who you know and and you know, I I got I can't even remember how I get in the back door, but I know you stuck a word in to to dig it for me, you know, you need to get this boy on and all that kind of stuff and sometimes it's just who you know gets gets you in and and nailed on there cuz I was an unknown guy at that point. So, uh you know, it's networking I think is a big big thing that doesn't cost you a huge amount of money. Um and you know, go out there, you know, you've done networking at you uh events and all that and you used to come to Chester um to do that very thing. So, yeah, I think that networking would be that. YouTube um are kind of low cost things, but obviously from the others. What would you say then for building a personal brand for getting on other people either building your own podcast and getting guests on and interviewing others or trying to to get on other people's podcasts as well to try and get in front of their followings try and start building that up.

Craig Campbell: You It's hard to get on other people's podcast to leverage their following. So, I get uh people come to me all the time saying, "I want this guy on your podcast. I want that guy on your podcast." I don't know who you are from Adam, so you're not getting on mine. You're going to have to earn my trust first before you're allowed to speak.

James Dooley: Yeah. Uh and you know, if you came to me and I didn't know you, I'd be like, "No, no way. You're rough as toast. I don't know what you're going to say."

Craig Campbell: Um and so, you're going to have to earn trust and you're going to have to make connections and you're going to have to smooth someone and you're going to have to bribe or you know, whatever your language is in. Uh you're going to have to work that. You can't just ping people and go, "I'm coming on your podcast." No, you're not. I don't know whether you actually make money or not. I don't know whether you're trustworthy or not or you you know you're going to say that that could get me into trouble or whatever. So, the podcast person's got all of that to contend with and it's the same with you. You get people going to I want to be in your podcast and you're like well, what's in it for me? And you know you've got nothing to bring to the table, no good jokes, no good banter, no good information or stuff. So, you're going to have to offer a lot of value up front and and build yourself up from the ground up. And I think that's that's the hard part. You can't just say here's a podcast booking agency who are going to get you on all of these top-tier podcasts. It's just not going to happen.

James Dooley: Yeah, you got to definitely build it. I think like I saw you did it a great a great way. Matt D'Avella did it. So, when he was not known at all within the industry, also what he did he hanged about on Reddit, Facebook groups. Facebook groups was probably the biggest one he was doing and what he was doing he was looking for questions that people had and he was going, could I create a blog post onto this or create a video on this? And he would never it would never answer the question with a with a comment with a reply. He would always go, okay, I can create there's enough volume I can create a post on this. Do it in-depth or do it video on it and it always always post the the actual post or the video. Once that happened the flywheel started to go cuz when somebody else in another group would ask a very similar question they would share an in-depth video or an in-depth blog post and just by literally churning out spending several hours every single day in networking, seeing people's problems, answering those problems with a good answer. Bit by bit then they started to get the trust or you want to speak to them or you want to speak to them. And obviously from there then the rest is history where he's built multiple brands, had a nice successful conference and stuff like that. Um but yeah, it's it's crazy. But you like you said it's difficult when you first starting out to build a personal brand.

Craig Campbell: Yeah. It is difficult. If So, let me if you could only choose three platforms, three social media platforms

James Dooley: Mhm.

Craig Campbell: to do personal branding on, which three would you choose? I'm only Let's say just for building out to be an SEO consultant. YouTube's number one. Uh

James Dooley: Yeah. That's probably LinkedIn. Um would be second. I'm not a big user of LinkedIn just because I think people talk pesh on it. Um It's very, very salesy, but I think exposure-wise and numbers-wise and business owner-wise and everything, you're probably in the right place there. Um I've got to say Facebook's always been I would probably argue myself a little bit on it, you know, what Facebook has been good for me personally. I don't think I enjoy Facebook as much as I used to, but Facebook I would probably say still got to be up there for me. A lot of SEOs are on Facebook. Uh you know, we look at our mutual connections, it's just outrageous. So, I'd probably say those three. What about you?

Craig Campbell: Yeah. I'd say it was a bad question that I asked you. When I asked you the question, then I'm thinking it should just be all platforms. Like, you should just with AI now, it's so easy now to be able to send the same intent but throughout all platforms.

James Dooley: I would kind of disagree on that. I don't think Instagram does much for me. Like, from an SEO

Craig Campbell: Well, do you know what? Do you know what's really interesting, man? On Meta, both Facebook and Instagram the last 12 months have been really growing on index pages. And actually, by getting the words in the images that's on Instagram, you can actually now start manipulating the LLMs. So, just for that reason, I'd be like, "Okay, let's grab that. Let's put it into an image. Let's put the text in the status, and then let's force index it." But I agree. I feel like trying to grow the audience on Instagram is a slog, man. It's a slog, isn't I tell you a funny story around that. So, obviously I had my health issues last year. I'm not going to document what exactly those are cuz it's a bit grim. Um but after Cas's conference last year, I don't know why, but I I just decided to put into ChatGPT "Has Craig Campbell uh been ill recently?" Cuz everyone kept asking me how I was doing and all that stuff and it came up uh saying, "Yep, he's been ill. Um he's been in hospital, blah blah blah blah." And it was pulling from an Instagram post that I'd put when I was in hospital. So, when you see that

James Dooley: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, you're right. Uh and that happened to me and it's like, "Yep, he's been in hospital and here's the proof or here's the source." Uh and I'm like, "Oh." So, you know, from that, you your point is exactly valid, but just posting on Instagram, I just don't think

Craig Campbell: From a following, I get it. It's the hardest one. one of them all. So, uh and and I also feel that Twitter's kind of toxic. I've also found it Tik Tok is not great for SEO stuff. I I just think Tik Tok would work really well if you were a trying to be an influencer or maybe selling cars or selling something a bit more visual. I just think most people on Tik Tok are just like, "I don't even know what SEO is." So, um maybe AI will be different for Tik Tok. So, there's just certain platforms where I'm like, "I'm not going to spend that much time uh pushing them just for that reason alone." But it's it's probably why it's to use them all.

James Dooley: Yeah, for sure. And to all those watching this, we hope you like the episode on is personal branding important. If you think we've missed anything, any platform like Threads or podcasting circuits and stuff like that that you think's really important for the future of personal brands, leave a comment in the comment section. Craig, it's been an absolute pleasure. Thanks again, mate.

No episode selected
0:00
0:00